shakaizen
Why You Find Meditation Hard (You're Doing concentration)
You sit down to meditate. You close your eyes. You try to focus on your breath or a mantra or nothing at all. Within thirty seconds your mind wanders. You notice you’re thinking about work, redirect attention back to the breath. Ten seconds later you’re planning dinner. You bring yourself back. Your knee hurts. You adjust. Your back hurts You refocus. You’re thinking again. You’ve been sitting for three minutes and you’ve redirected your attention forty times. You open your eyes feeling like you failed at the simplest possible task: sitting still and paying attention.
Meditation apps tell you this is normal, that meditation is just noticing when your mind wanders and bringing it back. Ten minutes a day will reduce stress, improve focus, and change your life. But the experience feels nothing like what’s described. It’s not peaceful. It’s not transformative. It’s exhausting and frustrating, and the constant mental ping-ponging makes you feel like you’re terrible at something everyone else seems to find easy.
Here’s what nobody tells you: you’re not bad at meditation. You’re not even doing meditation. You’re attempting concentration practice—dharana—without the preparatory work that makes concentration possible. And concentration is extraordinarily difficult even when you’ve done the preparation. The reason meditation feels hard is because what you’re calling meditation is actually the prerequisite practice, and you’re trying to do it without building the capacity it requires.
What You Think Meditation Is
Contemporary meditation instruction describes a practice you can learn in ten minutes: sit comfortably, close your eyes, focus attention on an object (breath, body sensations, mantra, visualization), notice when your mind wanders, and gently redirect attention back to the object. Repeat for 10-20 minutes daily. That’s meditation. Simple, accessible, secular, evidence-based for stress reduction.
This description makes meditation sound easy. The instructions are straightforward. The time commitment is minimal. Millions of people do it. Apps provide guided sessions that walk you through exactly what to do. The marketing promises real benefits—reduced anxiety, improved focus, better sleep—backed by neuroscience research. All you need to do is sit still and pay attention for a few minutes daily.
The experience contradicts the promise. Sitting still is physically uncomfortable. Your back aches, your knees hurt, your neck gets stiff. Paying attention is mentally exhausting. Your mind wanders constantly despite your intention to focus. You spend most of the session noticing you’re distracted and redirecting attention, which itself requires mental effort. Instead of feeling peaceful, you feel frustrated. Instead of reduced stress, you experience the stress of repeated failure at a supposedly simple task.
You conclude you’re bad at meditation. Your mind is too active. You’re not disciplined enough. You don’t have the temperament for it. Other people can sit peacefully for twenty minutes—you can barely manage three before you’re overwhelmed by mental noise and physical discomfort. The problem must be you.
What Meditation Actually Is
Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras describe meditation—dhyana—as the seventh limb in an eight-limbed path. The sixth limb is dharana, concentration. The distinction matters: dharana is effortful holding of attention on a single object. Dhyana is effortless flow of attention on that object. Dharana, concentration, is what you do. Dhyana, meditation, is what arises when dharana is sustained without interruption.
Sutra 3.1 defines dharana: deśa bandhaś cittasya dhāraṇā—binding consciousness to a single place. This is concentration. You choose an object (breath, mantra, visualization) and hold attention there. When attention wanders, you redirect it. This requires continuous effort. You’re actively maintaining focus against the mind’s natural tendency to wander.
Sutra 3.2 defines dhyana: tatra pratyaya ekatānatā dhyānam—sustained flow of awareness on that object. When dharana continues uninterrupted, the effort dissolves. Attention flows naturally toward the object without you maintaining it. You’re no longer redirecting repeatedly. The mind stays focused spontaneously. This is meditation. You cannot do it. It arises when conditions allow.
The progression is explicit: first you develop the capacity for dharana through practice. When dharana can be sustained without continuous redirection, dhyana emerges. And when dhyana continues so completely that even the sense of you meditating disappears, that’s samadhi—absorption. These aren’t different techniques. They’re stages that unfold naturally when capacity exists.
What meditation apps call “meditation” is actually dharana practice—training concentration capacity. Nothing wrong with this. Dharana is essential. But calling it meditation creates confusion about why it’s so difficult and what you’re actually training. You’re not failing at meditation. You’re doing exactly what dharana involves: repeatedly redirecting attention back to the object. The difficulty is the practice working.
Why Dharana Is So Hard
Concentration is extraordinarily difficult because your mind’s default mode is wandering. Neuroscience calls this the default mode network—the brain activity that emerges when you’re not focused on external tasks. It involves thinking about past and future, self-referential processing, daydreaming, planning, and ruminating. This isn’t dysfunction. It’s your brain’s resting state.
Dharana requires overriding this default mode and maintaining attention on a single object despite the brain’s tendency to return to self-referential processing. You’re asking your mind to do something completely unnatural to it: stay focused on something unchanging and relatively boring (breath sensations, mantra repetition) for extended periods without wandering to more interesting territory.
The effort required is real. Studies using fMRI show that sustained attention activates the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex and anterior cingulate cortex—the same regions involved in executive function, working memory, and inhibitory control. Concentration is cognitive work. It depletes mental resources the same way sustained physical effort depletes physical resources. Feeling mentally exhausted after twenty minutes of attempting dharana isn’t failure—it’s evidence you’re actually doing the practice.
The challenge compounds because you notice every failure. In most difficult tasks, you can see progress—you lift heavier weights, run farther, solve harder problems. In dharana practice, progress means noticing more quickly when attention wanders. This feels like getting worse. You become aware of how constantly your mind moves, how little control you actually have, how even three breaths of uninterrupted attention is exceptional. The increased awareness of distraction feels like regression, but it’s actually refinement of meta-attention—the ability to notice when you’re distracted.
The Preparation You Skipped
Patanjali places dharana as the sixth limb, after yama (ethical restraints), niyama (observances), asana (seat), pranayama (breath regulation), and pratyahara (sense withdrawal). This sequence isn’t arbitrary. Each stage builds capacity required for the next. Attempting dharana without the preceding limbs is like attempting advanced mathematics without learning arithmetic—the foundation simply isn’t there.
Asana—the third limb—is mistranslated as “postures” or “yoga poses.” Patanjali’s definition in Sutra 2.46 is sthira sukham āsanam—steady and comfortable seat. The purpose isn’t fitness or flexibility. It’s developing the physical capacity to sit still for extended periods without discomfort that hijacks attention. If your back aches, your knees hurt, or your neck gets stiff after five minutes, you don’t have stable asana. Your body demands attention that should be directed toward your concentration object.
Most contemporary practitioners spend years practicing asana but never develop stable sitting capacity because they’re practicing dynamic movement sequences, not working toward steady comfortable stillness. The flowing vinyasa sequences that dominate studios don’t build the specific capacity dharana requires—they build cardiovascular fitness and muscular strength. Different goals, different outcomes.
Pranayama—the fourth limb—regulates vital energy through breath control, which directly affects nervous system stability. Erratic breathing patterns reflect and reinforce erratic mental states. Systematic breath regulation creates the physiological foundation for mental steadiness. Attempting concentration practice with unregulated breath is attempting to still the mind while the nervous system remains agitated. The mind won’t settle if the energy system it rides on is unstable.
Pratyahara—the fifth limb—is sense withdrawal, learning to disengage attention from sensory input. Your attention by default flows outward toward sights, sounds, sensations, thoughts about external things. Pratyahara is the capacity to redirect attention inward and hold it there despite sensory stimuli. Without this capacity, every sound, every sensation, every flicker of light pulls attention away from your concentration object.
They’re the foundation concentration requires. Most people attempting meditation have skipped all of them. They sit in uncomfortable positions, with unregulated breath, with attention habitually flowing outward, and try to concentrate. The difficulty isn’t personal failing. It’s attempting advanced practice without basic capacity.
What the Industry Promises vs. What Texts Teach
Meditation apps promise accessible practice: ten minutes daily produces measurable benefits in weeks. Neuroscience validates the effects—reduced anxiety, improved focus, decreased rumination, increased gray matter in attention-related brain regions. The research is real. The benefits are legitimate. The timeline is misleading.
The studies showing meditation benefits typically involve participants practicing 30-45 minutes daily for eight weeks in structured programs with instruction and support. That’s 168-252 hours of practice over two months. This isn’t casual ten-minutes-before-bed practice. It’s significant time investment with proper technique. Even then, the benefits are modest—moderate reductions in stress and anxiety, small improvements in attention metrics. Real, but not transformative.
Classical texts describe timelines in years, not weeks. The Hatha Yoga Pradipika and Yoga Sutras don’t promise quick results. They describe systematic progression through preliminary practices before dharana becomes sustainable, then continued practice until dhyana arises naturally, which might never happen. The honest teaching is that most practitioners will spend years developing concentration capacity and may never experience actual meditation (dhyana) at all.
Dharana—sustained one-pointed concentration—is a significant achievement requiring years of practice. It’s also useful on its own. The capacity to maintain focus without constant mental wandering improves thinking, decision-making, and emotional regulation even if dhyana never arises. But it’s not easy, it’s not quick, and it requires preparation most contemporary practitioners skip entirely.
The industry can’t sell this honestly. “Download our app and struggle with concentration practice for years with no guarantee of reaching actual meditation” doesn’t convert users. “Ten minutes daily for stress reduction backed by science” converts millions. The promise is technically accurate—brief concentration practice does reduce stress compared to no practice—but it fundamentally misrepresents what meditation is and what capacity it requires.
What Hard Actually Means
The difficulty of meditation isn’t dramatic. You’re not scaling cliffs or solving impossible problems. You’re sitting still trying to pay attention to your breath. The challenge is that this simple task reveals how little control you have over your own attention. Your mind does what it wants. You can intend to focus on breathing, but intention doesn’t translate to ability. The gap between wanting to concentrate and actually concentrating is where the difficulty lives.
This specific difficulty—sustained attention on an unchanging object despite constant mental wandering—isn’t something modern life trains. Contemporary existence is designed around attention fragmentation: social media, email notifications, multitasking, constant input switching. You’re training your attention to fragment and jump continuously. Then you sit down to meditate and try to do the opposite: sustain focus on a single object without jumping. It’s like training sprinting then wondering why marathons feel impossible.
The difficulty also isn’t progressive in satisfying ways. In most skills, you get noticeably better over time. In dharana practice, improvement means noticing distraction slightly faster and redirecting slightly more efficiently. You go from sustaining attention for two breaths to sustaining it for five breaths over months of practice. The gains are minute, the timeline is extended, and there’s no dramatic breakthrough moment where suddenly you can concentrate. It’s grinding, subtle refinement that never feels impressive.
This is why most people quit. The practice doesn’t match expectations. It’s supposed to be relaxing—it’s mentally exhausting. It’s supposed to reduce stress—struggling with your own mind for twenty minutes is stressful. It’s supposed to get easier with practice—it gets slightly less impossible but never actually easy. The gap between marketing promises and lived experience is large enough that most practitioners conclude they’re doing it wrong or they’re not suited for meditation, rather than recognizing that what they’re experiencing is exactly what dharana practice involves.
Why This Matters for Practice
Understanding that you’re practicing dharana, not dhyana, changes expectations appropriately. You’re not failing at meditation. You’re doing concentration training, which is extremely difficult and supposed to feel like continuous effort. The mental wandering isn’t your personal failing. It’s the normal condition you’re working with. Progress isn’t measured by peaceful states but by subtle improvements in how quickly you notice distraction and how efficiently you redirect attention.
This reframes practice from “achieving meditation” to “developing concentration capacity.” Different goal, different metric, different timeline. You’re not trying to have peaceful experiences. You’re training a specific mental capacity the way you’d train cardiovascular endurance or muscular strength. The training is uncomfortable, improvement is gradual, and there’s no finish line where suddenly you’re good at it—just incremental capacity development over extended time.
It also clarifies what preparation helps. If sitting physically hurts, work on asana—not flowing sequences, but finding a position you can maintain comfortably for 30+ minutes. If your breath is erratic, work on pranayama—not complex techniques, but establishing natural, regulated breathing patterns. If external stimuli constantly pull your attention, work on pratyahara—practicing disengagement from sensory input before attempting sustained concentration.
Meditation is hard because what you’re calling meditation is actually concentration training, and concentration is extraordinarily difficult. Your mind wanders constantly because that’s its default mode. Redirecting attention repeatedly is mentally exhausting because it’s genuine cognitive work. You feel like you’re failing because you expect peaceful states but experience continuous effort instead.
None of this means you’re bad at it. It means you’re doing exactly what the practice involves. Dharana is sustained attention despite constant distraction. The difficulty is the practice. The wandering mind isn’t the problem—it’s what you’re working with. Progress isn’t measured by lack of distraction but by faster recognition of distraction and more efficient redirection.
The practice gets marginally less impossible over months and years. You might eventually sustain attention for ten breaths instead of three. You might notice distraction within seconds instead of minutes. These are real improvements even though they don’t feel dramatic. And if you practice long enough with proper preparation—stable asana, regulated pranayama, sense withdrawal capacity—you might occasionally experience moments where attention flows naturally without effort. That’s dhyana. It’s rare, it can’t be forced, and it arises when conditions align rather than through technique mastery.
Most people would be better served by honest dharana practice with appropriate expectations than by pursuing “meditation” with promises of quick stress relief. Concentration capacity is genuinely useful even if you never experience actual meditation. But it requires years of practice, preparatory work most people skip, and tolerance for something that remains difficult indefinitely. The reason you find meditation hard is because you’re attempting something genuinely difficult while expecting it to be easy. Adjusting expectations to match reality makes the practice sustainable. Whether it’s worth sustaining depends entirely on whether developing concentration capacity matters to you more than feeling peaceful quickly.
About Shakaizen
Shakaizen offers private yoga and meditation retreats in the Himalayas (Manali, Dharamshala, Leh) and Japan (Nara, Kyoto, Nagano), teaching classical practices from source texts—Yoga Sutras, Hatha Yoga Pradipika, Bhagavad Gita, Upanishads. Transmission of what yoga was before commercialization diluted it into fitness and Instagram poses. Maximum 4 people per retreat, adapted to your capacity, taught by someone who’s lived this for 15+ years.